Fake subscribers vs real engagementFake subscribers vs real engagement

In today’s digital era, subscriber count can be misleading if not paired with actual engagement metrics.
We analyzed two of Indiaโ€™s biggest YouTube channels โ€” Narendra Modi and Dhruv Rathee โ€” to understand the gap between subscriber numbers and actual viewer activity.


๐Ÿ“ Engagement Calculations Breakdown

Letโ€™s dive into the raw data and estimate how many of these subscribers are actually active โ€” and how many may be inactive or fake.


๐Ÿ”ธ Channel A โ€” Narendra Modi

  • Subscribers: 28.5 Million

  • Expected Real Views (5% industry avg.):
    28.5M ร— 0.05 = 1,425,000

  • Actual Views on Recent Video: 7,700

  • View Reach %:
    (7,700 รท 28,500,000) โ‰ˆ 0.027%

  • ๐Ÿ’ก Active Subscriber Estimate:
    Assuming active users view 1 in 5 videos:
    7,700 ร— 5 = 38,500 active subscribers

  • โ— Inactive/Fake Subscribers:
    28,500,000 โˆ’ 38,500 = 28,461,500


๐Ÿ”ธ Channel B โ€” Dhruv Rathee

  • Subscribers: 29.1 Million

  • Expected Real Views (5%):
    29.1M ร— 0.05 = 1,455,000

  • Actual Views (recent video in 8 days): 18 Million

  • View Reach %:
    (18M รท 29.1M) โ‰ˆ 61.8%

  • ๐Ÿ’ก Active Subscriber Estimate:
    Given the high and consistent viewership:
    Estimated 20Mโ€“25M engaged subscribers

  • โ— Inactive/Fake Subscribers:
    29.1M โˆ’ 22M โ‰ˆ 7.1M (approx.)


โœ… Final Engagement Estimates (Rounded)

ChannelSubscribersActive SubsInactive/Fake SubsFake %
Narendra Modi28.5M~38K~28.46M~99.9% โŒ
Dhruv Rathee29.1M~22M~7M~24% โœ…

๐Ÿง What Does This Tell Us?

  • Dhruv Rathee has a remarkably high engagement rate, indicating a genuine, active following.

  • Narendra Modiโ€™s channel, despite its massive subscriber base, shows alarmingly low engagement โ€” which raises serious concerns about subscriber authenticity or possible algorithmic suppression.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *